Clicky

Barstooler who torched Riley Fibbers after getting kicked out gets a decade behind bars

|
Fire scene at Riley Fibbers last year and mugshot of the defendant.

Paul Lucia, 61, admitted he went back to the East Islip pub with a gas can and lighter two hours after staff showed him the door

An Islip Terrace man who got booted from an East Islip pub for taking a photo of a staffer, then came back with a gas can and a lighter, was sentenced Tuesday to 10 years in prison for setting the place on fire.

Paul Lucia, 61, pleaded guilty last month to second-degree arson in the Nov. 20, 2025, blaze at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant.

“What began as a simple request for the defendant to leave the premises escalated into an unwarranted and dangerous act of arson,” Suffolk District Attorney Raymond Tierney said.

Gas can in tow

Court documents indicate Lucia was a patron at the Carleton Avenue pub when at about 5:30 p.m. staff asked him to leave because he had taken a picture of a worker.

Lucia drove off in a white Jeep Patriot, then came back about 7:30 p.m.

Surveillance video captured him climbing out of his vehicle and dumping liquid from a gas can near the rear entrance. The bar door was open, and patrons and employees were there, prosecutors said.

Flames erupted moments later as Lucia walked back to the Jeep. He threw the gas can over a fence onto the neighboring property and drove off, prosecutors said.

The fire damaged an exterior awning and the kitchen. No one was injured, authorities said. The pub closed temporarily after the fire, but reopened within weeks.

Trail of evidence

A witness gave police the Jeep’s license plate number. It turned out that the plates had been reported stolen a week before the fire, prosecutors said.

Suffolk Police Arson Squad detectives found the gas can’s cap in a flowerpot outside the bar and the can on the adjacent property.

The next day, Suffolk Police spotted the Jeep on Sunrise Highway and pulled Lucia over. During his arrest, officers found the lighter used in the fire inside his car.

Lucia pleaded guilty before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard Horowitz to second-degree arson, third-degree arson, and two counts of fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property.

Click here for Greater Long Island newsletters.

Top: Paul Lucia, 61, in a mugshot layered over a photo of the Nov. 20, 2025, fire scene at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant in East Islip (Facebook/Islip Fire Department and SCDA).

Your Long Island news, delivered.

Your Long Island news, delivered.

Subscribe to the GLI Newsletter — its free

Our Local Supporters

Cops & Courts