
Greater Smithtown coverage is funded in part by Keith Dawson of The Dawson Team of Signature Premier Properties. Click here to view current listings.
Smithtown is gearing up to welcome a new dining destination as The Pizzeria prepares to open its doors on Main Street in early spring, ownership told Greater Long Island.
The Smithtown location will mark the Long Island company’s seventh restaurant since its debut in 2020, joining existing spots in Bay Shore, Lindenhurst, Islip, Bayport, Lake Grove, and Babylon.
Located at 88 Main St., the 3,000-square-foot eatery replaces Buona Sera Pizzeria and will feature a full-service bar, seating for 75 guests, and dine-in waitress service, along with a classic slice counter. The Pizzeria team fully gutted and renovated the space. The following photos were taken in January:



“We’ve had a lot of requests from customers to expand to Smithtown,” said Cliff Weinstein, a member of the ownership team, previously told GLI. “It’s a vibrant area with a demographic that matches the community-focused atmosphere we aim to create.”
Beyond serving its renowned pizza, the restaurant group’s growth is fueled by its commitment to hospitality — not just for its patrons but also for its employees, Weinstein said.
The company places a strong emphasis on staff satisfaction, with such initiatives as appointing a chief happiness officer and a performance coach to help employees achieve personal and professional fulfillment.
“We’ve learned that investing in our team’s happiness leads to better experiences for our guests,” Weinstein explained. “Our goal is to create a platform for growth. Whether employees stay with us long-term or use this as a stepping stone, we want to ensure they thrive.”
Stay tuned to Greater Long Island for updates on the new Smithtown location.
Top photo: The Pizzeria Islip.