Click here for Greater Long Island newsletters. Click here to download the iPhone app. Or follow GLI on Apple News!
“Leaving was bittersweet. Coming back was also bittersweet.”
Garrett Klein reopened Vincenzo’s Pizza in Levittown on Wednesday, Nov. 18, just 18 days after serving what he thought was his last slice.
Klein closed the Wantagh Avenue pizzeria on Halloween, hoping to spend more time at home with his son, who is nearly 11 months old. Then the planned sale fell through.
“The only way to put it was we had to get back into the store because we had to pay rent and stuff,” Klein told Greater Long Island.
Klein and his fiancée used the time to give the shop a new look. They brightened up the space and changed the decor, with more updates on the way.
The menu has a few additions, too. Chicken vodka burrata comes as a hero or as an entree with pasta. A new Buffalo chicken hero comes with provolone, pickled red onions, celery, lettuce and ranch dressing. All heroes are now served on semolina bread.
Klein is also working on new pizzas, including “classic pies inspired by friends and different takes on pies I’ve come across on social media.”
When Klein announced Vincenzo’s was closing on Halloween, customers poured in to say goodbye. Some had been coming in since they were kids.
“I watched them grow up from little tykes,” Klein said with a laugh. “Now, they are getting ready to graduate.”
Klein said the support meant a lot to him. Now that he’s back, he’s looking forward to his son growing up around those same customers.
“It’s cool that they’ll be able to watch him grow up, like I watched their kids grow up,” he said.
Top: Garrett Klein, left, poses with two others at Vincenzo’s Pizza in Levittown. (GLI/Andrew Rappaport)




















