Petition to halt ‘McMansions’ sparks heated debate in Valley Stream, beyond

A growing debate over oversized homes in Nassau County neighborhoods has spilled onto social media, as residents clash over whether so-called McMansions are changing the character of their communities or simply accommodating larger or extended families.

An online petition calling for a moratorium on oversized residential construction and tougher enforcement of overnight parking restrictions has drawn attention in a Valley Stream community Facebook group, where residents are weighing in on everything from property values to zoning laws.

The Change.org petition, launched June 23 by residents of Elmont represented by the Parkhurst Civic Association and six other civic associations, urges the Town of Hempstead to address what organizers describe as a growing problem involving oversized homes and commercial vehicles parked in residential neighborhoods.

Organizers contend that modest single-family houses are being replaced or converted into large, multistory dwellings, some allegedly housing multiple families.

They also raise concerns about taxis and ride-share vehicles being parked overnight on neighborhood streets.

The petition had attracted 283 signatures as of Wednesday morning.

A second petition

A separate petition focused on Valley Stream, Elmont and Franklin Square has gained even more traction, collecting 398 signatures as of Wednesday morning.

That petition, launched July 13 by North Valley Stream Neighbors for Responsible Growth, alleges that developers are replacing modest homes with structures exceeding 5,000 square feet on lots traditionally occupied by much smaller houses.

Organizers say the construction is creating parking problems, reducing privacy, removing mature trees and placing additional demands on neighborhood infrastructure.

They are calling for a review of Hempstead Town’s zoning regulations, a temporary halt to certain demolition and construction permits while those rules are examined, and a public forum where residents can voice their concerns.

The petition emphasizes that its supporters are not opposed to development itself, but want new construction to fit the scale of existing neighborhoods.

Online debate

The issue has sparked sharply divided reactions in the Valley Stream Community Facebook group, where some residents argue that the new homes look out of place.

“I’m sorry, but when you have like a huge mini mansion size Home in a residential neighborhood with normal size homes, it looks ridiculous,” wrote Sara Schaefer.

Others defended the construction, saying larger homes are increasingly necessary for extended families living under one roof.

“These house are being built because families are living together. A 1200 sq ft home is just not big enough,” wrote Yohan Paul Isaac, who dismissed the petition as unnecessary.

Isaac later argued that larger homes could actually benefit surrounding property owners.

“Is someone supposed to build a small house because every house around them is small?” he wrote. “I thought the goal is to do better and improve.”

Another commenter, Parodi Elisabeth, offered a simpler response: “Let them be … silly trying to control what others can do with their money.”

Some residents raised concerns about multiple households occupying single-family homes and the potential effects on schools and local taxes.

Those claims were not independently verified.

Michael Belfiore, meanwhile, questioned whether the disputed houses comply with existing zoning regulations or require special approvals.

“The question is do are these houses built within the existing zoning code or are variances granted?” he wrote. “This is important to know if you want our elected leaders to take action.”

The petitions are directed at Hempstead Town officials, who oversee zoning in the town’s unincorporated communities.

The Village of Valley Stream has its own municipal government and zoning regulations.

Neither petition establishes that specific construction projects have violated local zoning laws.

---

Top: Two new homes under construction on relatively small plot of land on Long Island. GLI is withholding the exact address for privacy reasons. (Credit: GLI/Mike White)