Clicky

Off-season escape: A night at the 98-year-old Montauk Yacht Club

|
Montauk Yacht Club viewed from the dock.

The historic Star Island resort, built by the man who made Miami Beach, gets quiet and romantic once the summer crowds clear out

A chilled bottle of champagne. A pocket-size sandy beach right outside the patio door. A toilet paper roll creatively folded into a tiny sailboat.

That’s how the Montauk Yacht Club welcomes you, and it sets the tone for a stay that’s all about small, thoughtful touches.

Greater Long Island spent a night at the historic Star Island resort this month. The summer crowds were long gone, and Montauk had slowed to a nice, off-season pace. If you’ve written off the East End until Memorial Day, the Montauk Yacht Club is happy to prove you wrong.

A 1920s dream on Lake Montauk

The 60-foot lighthouse replica that developer Carl Fisher built at the Montauk Yacht Club in the late 1920s still stands on Star Island (Brian Harmon photo).

The Montauk Yacht Club has stood on Star Island since 1928, when developer Carl Fisher opened it as part of his grand plan to turn Montauk into the “Miami Beach of the North.” Fisher had already converted a Florida swamp into Miami Beach.

In 1927, he used dynamite to cut a channel between Lake Montauk, then a freshwater lake, and Block Island Sound, turning the lake into a harbor for the yachts of his wealthy pals.

The club’s early members included the Astors, Whitneys and Vanderbilts. Charles Lindbergh once flew in, splashing his seaplane down on Lake Montauk.

Fisher also built a 60-foot replica of the Montauk Point Lighthouse on the property. It still glows today.

But Montauk dream didn’t last. The Great Depression wiped out his fortune. Nonetheless, the yacht club survived him.

The resort has had a busy few years. Gurney’s bought the property in 2018, renamed it Gurney’s Star Island Resort & Marina, and reportedly put $13 million into refurbishing it. After Safe Harbor Marinas acquired it, the resort went back to its historic name, while undergoing two rounds of multimillion-dollar renovations in 2023 and 2024.

Meanwhile, Safe Harbor entrusted Proper Hospitality to take over operations of the club, which then featured refreshed rooms, suites and common areas and a new restaurant, Alba Spiaggia.

Today, the 16-acre resort has 107 rooms and three pools (including a modest-sized heated one inside). Above all, it boasts a front row view of the largest marina in the Hamptons. The marina counts more than 200 slips, handling superyachts up to 300 feet long.

The room

Our first-floor room, with a king-size bed, sat right on the water. Steps from the door was the resort’s small, quaint sandy beach, which felt like our own. Even in November, it was mild enough outside to leave the sliding door cracked open and fall asleep to the sound of Lake Montauk lapping at the beach.

The space’s nautical theme is subtle but unmistakable. It runs through the mirror, the lamps and the headboard without ever going overboard into kitsch. The bathroom is bright, roomy, and fully equipped with the necessities. Even a yoga mat is provided.

The view, minus the yachts

In summer, the marina is packed with yachts. In November, the slips sit empty, and that turns out to be a gift. With nothing blocking the view, Lake Montauk opens up wide and calm, especially at dawn and dusk.

The Saturday of our stay, the resort was hosting a wedding, and some of the excitement spilled over to the rest of us. We watched guests arrive and saw the young bride embrace a few of them. Later, from a room overlooking the lake, she was getting her makeup done. She looked out and gave us a wave. It was a sweet reminder of why so many couples pick this place to celebrate their big day.

A bride gets ready for her wedding in a room overlooking Lake Montauk (Brian Harmon/GLI photo).

Dinner, light and lovely

We kept dinner light at Alba Spiaggia, sharing a rigatoni in a thick tomato sauce that was absolutely delicious and a order of tasty grilled artichokes.

Two spicy margaritas were on point. To cap off the night, the bartender helped us pick a smooth Malbec.

The people

Kyle greets guests at the Montauk Yacht Club’s front desk (Brian Harmon/GLI).

It was raining when we pulled up, and the doormen hurried out to get our bags inside. Bellman Eric helped with our luggage. At the front desk, Kyle (mornings and afternoons) and Eddie (evenings) were friendly and helpful throughout.

Eddie hooked us up with an early check-in and helped schedule our dinner. When we forgot a toothbrush, a dental kit was waiting just down the hall.

The restaurant staff was polished and professional from start to finish.

Summer in Montauk means traffic, crowds and waits. The off-season trades all that for empty docks, quiet walks across the grounds and a slower pace that suits a couple’s getaway.

Nearly a century after Carl Fisher dreamed it up, the Montauk Yacht Club is still a place to get away from it all, and in November there’s a lot less “all” to get away from.

The Montauk Yacht Club is at 32 Star Island Road in Montauk. For rates and availability, visit montaukyachtclub.com.

More to see

The Montauk Yacht Club’s lighthouse replica glows over the waterfront path and Lake Montauk after dark (Brian Harmon/GLI).
The Montauk Yacht Club’s small private beach sits just steps from its first-floor waterfront rooms; here a guest takes in the view (Brian Harmon/GLI).
First-floor rooms at the Montauk Yacht Club open onto covered patios steps from the lawn, with the resort’s lighthouse replica rising behind them (Brian Harmon/GLI).
The Montauk Yacht Club’s spacious outdoor bar is quiet in November, but quite lively during peak season (Brian Harmon/GLI).
Bikes lined up for guests to use free of charge at the Montauk Yacht Club (Brian Harmon/GLI).
It certainly feels like you have your own private little beach at the Montauk Yacht Club on Star Island (Brian Harmon/GLI).
Everything looks new and super fresh and clean in the indoor pool area of the Montauk Yacht Club (Brian Harmon/GLI).
There’s plenty of space by the pool during swimming season at the Montauk Yacht Club (Brian Harmon/GLI).

The fitness center at the Montauk Yacht Club (Brian Harmon/GLI).

Click here for Greater Long Island newsletters.

Greater Long Island’s stay was provided by the Montauk Yacht Club.

Your Long Island news, delivered.

Your Long Island news, delivered.

Subscribe to the GLI Newsletter — its free

Our Local Supporters

Cops & Courts