New Mexican restaurant opens in Bay Shore


The wait is over for Pecado Mexican.

The Mexican-inspired eatery has finally swung open its doors in downtown Bay Shore this month.

Owner Ian Coughlin took over the former Barn Door 49 spot on West Main Street in the 2019-20 winter.

Since then, he’s been hard at work transforming the 2,700-square-foot space into his dream Mexican establishment.

Opening day was last Thursday, according to a Facebook post.

“We’re going to offer high-end authentic Mexican food in a casual atmosphere,” he previously told us. “You can come with your colleague from work for lunch, come here with your partner for a dinner date or you can bring your grandparents.

Coughlin also added a staple in the establishment will be the bar stocked with over 200 tequilas and 50 Mezcals.

Read more about Pecado Mexican by clicking our prior coverage below.

Top: Tacos from Pecado Mexican, courtesy of Facebook.